Choosing The Best Fish Grilling Basket (A Definitive Guide For Cooking Seafood Over Coals)

Spring has sprung. Summer is finally here and pretty soon it will be time to dust off the BBQ for another season of outdoor cookery and alfresco dining.

Weather permitting.....

best fish grilling basket

Meat eaters are always well catered for at barbecues. Steaks, burgers, ribs, chicken and chops are all easy and hassle free to cook over coles.

For pescetarians it's a different story.

Cooking fish presents its own unique set of issues even when your indoors, baking in your oven, or frying on the stove top.

Throw some open flames into the mix and the risk of over cooking, burning, leaving it raw in the middle, or just not quite getting it right multiply.

Not only that, but the delicate sweet flesh of fish can easily break apart and disappear right before your eyes in a flurry of flakes through your grill on to the hot coals.

So, if you want to avoid this particular culinary disaster than it's probably time to invest in a good fish grilling basket.

If your in a hurry below are a few examples.

More...

A Quick Look At Some Of The Best Fish Grilling Baskets.


Qualitech​​​​ Stainless Steel Grilling Basket

The Qualitech 430 stainless steel grill basket has got a unique custom design. With 3 folding sections and a removable handle it collapses away neatly for easy storage and transport. So its Ideal if your going camping. Each section measures 4.5 inches wide so you can cook up to 3 fish at once or multiple items think, burgers, chicken or veggies. Made from high quality 430 grade steel the qualitech won't rust and comes with a full warranty and a free pair of gloves.

The YeeTeching Basket



The Yeeteching grill basket comes with a generous 13 inch cooking surface making it ideal for those who want to cook multiple fish at once. Its thick gauge stainless steel bars firmly hold food in place, give good heat distribution, and are easy to clean. It comes with a lockable, folding, heat resistant handle for easy storage.

Weber Large Fish Grill Basket


The Weber stainless steel grill basket is made from a flexible wire mesh that makes it ideal for grilling delicate food items like fish fillets. At 18 by 10 inches it can easily accommodate 4 or 5 fillets depending on size so its a good option if your cooking for a crowd.  Its elevated side handles raise the food above the grill for Evan cooking. Its dishwasher safe but not really designed for cooking large whole fish

Jenify Grilled Fish Clip


The Jenify Fish clip is a fish shaped grill basket designed for cooking large fish up to 1.5 kg on the bone. The cooking area is 14.5 by 5,5 Inch wide. The thick wide set bars of the basket are durable and easy to clean. While the wooden handle is just long enough to keep you a nice distance from the heat.

GrillPro Fish Grill Basket


This fish grill basket from grill pro comes withe a detachable handle and a non-stick finish for easy clean up. At 16 inch wide its capable of holding a large fish for grilling on the bone. But because of the three height adjustable settings you could possibly use it for other foods too.

Why Evan Use A Grill Basket?

The best fish grilling baskets make cooking fish over coals child's play. You'll find it easy to flip the fish over and move it around for even cooking.

You'll easily be able to lift the fish off the grill and check if it's cooked without burning the handoff yourself.

Best of all, you'll have an awesome tasting piece of fish. With that unique smoky flavour and a moist succulent centre that you only get from cooking over red hot coals

No more worrying about an expensive piece of bass, salmon, or tuna disintegrating and having nothing to serve to your mates who’ve popped round for dinner and a few cold beers.

So, less stress and more time to spend with guests.

Choosing The Best Fish Grilling Basket - Why Size Matters

At the risk of stating the obvious, make sure you get a basket that will comfortably fit onto your char grill.

best fish grilling basket

You'll want your bed of coals to extend a good 6 inches out from the edge of your basket especially if you get one designed for cooking 3 or 4 fish at a time.

Here's the deal...

If your bbq is too small and your grill basket too big than the fish won't cook evenly. The fish in the middle will be overcooked while on the outside they'll be raw.

Having a bigger bed of coals also gives you more control if your cooking larger whole fish on the bone.

You can start them off in the centre of the grill where it's good and hot, then move them to the edge where its a little cooler for a more gentle and even cooking.

So, before you buy measure up and make sure you can get a good constant heat under all your fish at once.

Features To Look For In The Best Fish Grilling Basket

The best fish grilling baskets should be durable, able to withstand high temperatures and be easy to use and clean (more on this in a minute). 

That means a locking mechanism that is secure, bars that hold the fish firmly in place, and a handle that keeps you at a comfortable distance from the heat. 

Locking Mechanism

In my experience, the most dangerous part of grilling fish is when your flipping it.

If the basket lock slips at just the wrong moment your lovingly prepared fish might end up strewn across your grill.

So, get a basket that locks firmly and be extra careful when moving it around and when you're turning it.

Durability And Materials

These days most grill baskets are made from stainless steel or steel coated in chrome or some other type of non-stick coating like Teflon.

Stainless Steel

Stainless steel is cheap for both manufacturer and consumer, it can withstand wear and tear, won't rust. and you can put it in your dishwasher.

Try to avoid baskets with a thin wire mesh. Fish tends to stick easily to them and they can also warp and burn through after just a couple of uses.

The best fish grilling basket will have a thicker gauge bar that's more hard-wearing and made to last.

grilled fish

Enamel

Though not as widely available, enamel isn't a bad choice as a material for a grill basket.

Like stainless steel, it's strong, durable, and can withstand serious heat. Their also the best looking of the lot and easily cleaned in the dishwasher.

Unfortunately, no matter how careful you are after a while bits of enamel will inevitably chip off. 

So try not to bang it about too much and for heaven's sake don't drop it.

Cast Iron

Cast iron grill baskets are a bit old school but would be a favorite of most grill-masters.

All though they can be a little heavy, their really strong, and can tolerate the highest of temperatures.

They're also really easy to clean and are non stick if you season them with oil and salt just like you would a cast iron pan or a wok. 

Depth And Shape

Before you buy, give a little bit of thought to what cuts of fish your most lightly to cook.

Whole fish will need a lot more space then fillets and a deeper basket. Anything too tight could squash the fish like a pancake as it cooks.

If its fillets you plan on cooking than look for something shallower and a lot tighter that will hold the fish firmly in place.

Anything too loose and your fillets will flap about inside and there's a chance of them breaking up as they grill.

Handles

As a general rule the longer the handle the better. 

Your hands will be a good safe distance from the heat when tending to your fish.

Always use a pair of gloves though, because all grill baskets conduct heat and no matter what they're made of the handles will eventually get hot.

So safety first.......

When it comes to materials I nearly always look for something metal for the simple reason that their easier to keep clean.

Wood and rosewood handles look good when new but will eventually char from heat, get dirty, and harbor bacteria.

There are baskets out there with detachable handles which sound like a great idea, especially from a safety point of view.

Having never used one though, I can’t really comment.

I reckon that as long as their well designed and the handle is easy to attach/detach without too much fiddling around then they could be a good way to go.

What's The Best Fish Grilling Basket - The Contenders

Choosing the best fish grilling basket can be a daunting task. There's a lot of different styles and options to choose from, 

We’ve rounded up a review of five of the best, each with a slightly different design so that hopefully you'll find one that suits.

Here at Cockles n Mussels we hope you enjoy the products we recommend but we need to let you know that if you decide to purchase something through the links on this page we get a small commission. It helps keep the lights on round here.....Thanks.

Qualitech 430 Stainless Steel Grilling Basket

The Qualitech 430 is a stainless steel grilling basket that comes with a pair of heat resistant gloves. The wooden handle can be removed for use in a campfire or in an oven. Most notably, this basket is split into three individual sections for cooking a variety of items at once.

Pros

  •  Removable wooden handle means that you can pop this basket into the oven on a rainy day.
  • Having to prongs makes the basket easier to rest across a fire pit or other surface. This makes it ideal for campers who might not always have a grill around.
  • Long 11 inch (28 cm)  handle keeps your hands comfortably away from the heat. 

  • Very versatile, can be used in an oven or campfire. It also has three sections for adding veggies or other meat to the meal.
  • Comes with a free pair of heat resistant gloves, which is pretty nice
  • Dishwasher Safe...Need I say more? Points for easy cleanup.

Cons

  • The three individual sections of this basket are arn't huge, which makes it difficult to grill a larger whole fish on the bone.
  • The outer portion of the handle is metal unless the wooden handle is inserted. This makes the handle hot and difficult to pick up.

Yeeteching Grill Basket

The YeeTeching Fish Grill Basket is made of stainless steel and comes in at 13.8 inches wide (35 cm.) This basket features a simple secure sliding lock. The handle folds up for easier storage and it comes with a 2-year warranty.

Pros

  • This guy has a nice, large surface. That means you can cook a large piece of fish, several smaller pieces of fish, or even a bunch of shrimp in one go.
  • Folding handle reduces the footprint of this basket in your kitchen.
  • Machine Washable
  • Sturdy sliding lock keeps the basket firmly closed.
  • Very affordable, which is great news for those who aren't looking to put down a lot of money for a seasonal tool.

Cons

  • It's Big - If you don't have much space in your kitchen, this one might be a pass for you. Although its size is great while cooking, it isn't while it's in storage.
  • Short wooden Handle about 6 inches (16 cm) in length.

Jenify Grilled Fish Clip​​​​

The Jenify Grilled Fish Clip is a roughly fish-shaped grilling basket. The basket space clocks in at 14.5 inches (37 cm) long and 5.5 inches (14 cm) wide. The handle is about 12 inches (30 cm) long.

Pros

  • Fish Shaped so its ideal for whole fish on the bone.
  • Very long handle keeps you well away from the heat.
  •  Large capacity means this basket can handle a pretty large portion of fish, which is great news if you're cooking for a group.
  • It's easy to clean since this basket has wide-set wire supports instead of a grid,

Cons

  • Although there's plenty of room to cook other items in this basket, the shape really makes best for cooking only fish. This basket it less of a multitasker.

Weber 6471 Large Fish Basket

The most unique of the five on this list, the Weber 6471 Large Fish Basket is rectangular with a flexible stainless steel wire grid. It's double-sided handles raise the basket off the grates of the grill. It also features a proper locking mechanism, rather than a sliding lock. And if your cooking fillets this is probably the best fish grilling basket around,

Pros

  • The flexible wire makes it easier to cook whole fish without worrying whether the basket will close.
  • The handles lift it off the surface of the grill grates, which can help the fish cook more evenly.
  • Size - This thing is a whopper at 18 inches (46 cm) by 10.5 inches (27 cm.)

Cons

  • If the fish sticks, the flexible wire can be a real pain to clean.
  • Although it's nice that the handles add height from the grill grates, they are much harder to grip and since they're so close to the cooking surface you'll need heat protective gloves to do the job.
  • Size - Once again, size could be a blessing or a curse depending on your needs.

Outset Fish Grill Basket

Another affordable entry, the Outset QC70 features wide-set wire prongs in place of a mesh or grid and has a rosewood handle. The basket is another fish-shaped space.

Pros

  • Size - The basket space of this one is definitely roomy enough to hold a large whole fish.
  • Good looking - The rosewood handle on this basket is just aesthetically pleasing.
  • Like with the Jenify, the simple pattern on this basket makes it much easier to keep clean.

Cons

  • It's not stainless steel. That means it is not dishwasher safe and could rust over time.
  • Although well designed the quality of the steel isn't great. It's made of wire that's quite thin, which means it likely won't hold up as well over time. If you only grill fish occasionally though, then it wouldn't be a bad choice.

How much fish will you cook?

If you are the type of cook who mostly uses the grill when there's company, or if you have a family to feed, the size of your fish grill basket matters. 

Pick a basket that can hold a large fish (or several at a time) to make sure you’ve enough to feed everybody. 

If you mostly cook for yourself or for two, you will likely find that a smaller basket fits more neatly in your lifestyle and kitchen.

What will you be grilling?

If your reading this than the obvious answer here is, of course, fish. 

But presumably, you might also want to use your fish grilling basket for other foods like grilled pizzas, quesadillas, or more delicate vegetables like asparagus. 

If you're like me and plan on primarily using your basket for fish, you can choose a fish-shaped basket. 

Otherwise, keep an eye out for the shape and size that best suits.

Clean up

Call me lazy, but I hate washing up (who doesn't) 

Any time I’m buying something new for the kitchen the first question I ask myself is...

How easy will this be to clean?

All through your grill basket will be all shiny and new when it arrives it won’t stay that way for long.

After just a single use the gloss will come off.

But there are a couple of practical steps you can take during the cooking process to help keep it clean.

Firstly, only cook over red hot embers.

Cooking over naked flames will blacken your basket and your fish, cause a build-up of soot, and ultimately weaken and shorten your baskets life.

best fish grilling basket

Secondly, go easy on oil-based marinades.

Dripping oil causes flare-ups which like above will discolor you basket especially if you brush it on during cooking.

If you plan or marinating your fish don't leave it swimming in oil before it hits the grill. Just a light brush with an oil-based marinade is best.

Better still, look for a recipe like one of these that's not quite so oil-based. Or if your dead set on an oil marinade think about adding more of it just as the fish comes off the grill.

Your fish will still soak up lots of flavor as it cools and rests and will still taste great. 

Finally, try to make sure your fish doesn't get stuck to your basket

How to stop your fish Sticking

Fish sticking badly to a grill basket can be a bit of a nightmare.

Not only could you be left hungry but you'll have a bit of a job cleaning off all those burnt flakes that get stuck to the bars.

So, here's a couple of tips to help avoid this ordeal

  1. Cook your fish with the skin on- the flesh of fish is delicate. It can dry out quickly and easily become stuck. Leaving the skin and sometimes even the scales on your fish protects it from the heat. If you don't want to eat the skin its easily removed after cooking.
  2. Brush you basket with oil - A little oil helps lubricate things. Not too much though or you'll get flare-ups. One of those aerosol spray oils would be ideal for this job.
  3. Pre-heat the basket - Before the fish goes in, heat the basket on the coals for a couple of minutes. This helps seal the fish, it will begin to cook straight away, and there's less chance of it sticking.

Of course, if you want to avoid all this and for a little peace of mind than go for a non-stick basket 

Best Non-Stick Fish Grill basket

Below are a couple of examples of non-stick fish grill baskets you could consider.

GrillPro Detachable Handle Fish Basket

This grillpro fish shaped basket clocks in at a generous 16’’ in length so its capable of grilling a whole fish of between 2 and 4 lbs depending on the species (easily enough for 6/8 hungry mouths)

Pros

  • Non-stick.
  • Detachable rosewood handle.
  • Large enough to grill a whole fish up to 16 inches in length.
  • Comes apart and has a simple pattern for easy cleanup.
  • Adjustable height options with 3 settings.

Cons

  • The handle can be a little difficult to attach/detach.
  • Not designed for cooking delicate veggies like asparagus.
  • Not for the dishwasher if you want to keep the non-stick coating.

Char-Broil Non-Stick Grill Basket

This grill basket from Char-Broil is multi-use, Not only fish, but steaks, burgers, large vegetables, and chops all fit comfortably in its 10.5 by 10.5-inch frame. Easily enough to feed a large crowd of 8 /10 people

Pros

  • Great for grilling multiple whole fish at the same time.
  • Solid stainless steel construction.
  • Its close knit mesh means you can cook small items like shrimp or veggies without them falling through as well as burgers. chops, or whole fish
  • Non-stick for easy cleanup

Cons

  • Weighing in at 1,25lbs some might find this basket a bit heavy
  • Locking latch can be difficult to open and gets hot while on the grill.
  • No handle so you'll have to be careful and use a pair of oven mitts to turn it and lift it off the grill.

Fish You Can Grill Without A Basket

If you don’t have a fish grill basket or the hassle of cleaning one after a long day on the BBQ doesn't appeal there are a few species of fish that can go on the grill without one.

And lucky for me, they just happen to be some of my personal favorites. The guys over at char-broil have compiled a list here to which Ill add to a little.

Most flaky types of fish like salmon, cod, or haddock are always best grilled in a basket. But some species with a denser more tightly packed flesh can be cooked without one,

Tuna, swordfish, monkfish, and shark all fall into this category.

While certain type of whole fish like snapper or bass with the skin left on can also be cooked carefully on the BBQ.

best fish grilling basket

Some cuts of fish left on the bone like ray wings, sole, or troncons of brill or turbot also work well.

The Best Fish Grilling Basket - Wrapping up

Once you’ve decided how many people you need to feed and on the size of your basket than the choice of which one to go for comes down to one simple factor.

Is it fillets or whole fish you'll be grilling?

If its fillets than the weber would probably be your best option. Its flexible wire mesh will hold everything in place without too much flapping around.

If however, its whole fish your gonna cook than I really like the Qualitech. 

Its size gives you the flexibility to cook as much or as little as you need. Its multi-use and not just for fish, and on top of all that its hard wearing and easy to clean.

Best of luck and happy grilling....

Disclosure

cocklesandmussels.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc., or its affiliates.


Related Posts
No related posts for this content

Subscribe To Cockles N' Mussels

And receive recipes straight to your inbox every time we publish something new!

Your email will never be shared

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below